By Rabbi Rachel Esserman
I’d originally deleted the e-mail from The Nosher website featuring the article. Then I moved the e-mail back to my inbox and clicked through the link, copying and pasting the article into a document to read later. However, I still haven’t been able to get myself to look at it. Why? The article is called “The Jewish History of Margarine,” but to even consider the use of margarine was a blasphemy in my family. My mother would never let margarine darken our doors. What did we use instead? Butter and more butter, and nothing but butter, especially for baking.
I get why Jews looked for non-dairy variations of dairy food: that meant they could be eaten at a meat meal. For those who needed bread at a meal – no matter how many different kinds of food were on the table, my grandfather asked for bread! – butter certainly makes it more palatable. I remember when non-dairy creamers first began to be used: no matter how fancy a meal was, they came to the table in their original containers to show they were non-dairy. Now they are so common that no longer needs to be done.
However, back to butter. Someone once complained to my mother about a recipe my mom gave her, saying the item wasn’t as good as the one my mom made. What was my mom’s first question? “Did you use butter or margarine?” The answer was clear: margarine. After that, my mom would only give that recipe (and others) to people if they promised to use butter. (As an aside: someone once refused to give my mother a recipe for some dessert. I don’t remember what it was, but I know that my mom later found that recipe in The New York Times and made copies to pass to everyone she knew who baked.)
As a child, I was also a big butter fan. I would eat whole pats of butter in restaurants. (Yes, just the butter by itself.) When I dream of a bagel, I think of an onion one smothered in butter (meaning butter almost dripping from its sides). The fried butter on a stick that can be found at some state fairs doesn’t appeal to me, but that’s because my idea of healthy eating has changed. I don’t use much butter, but let’s be clear that pancakes, waffles and popcorn are better with butter. (As for popcorn, I mean real butter, not the stuff they use in movie theaters or on most microwave popcorn.)
Will I someday bother to go back and read the article about margarine? I doubt it. Even thinking about margarine seems a betrayal of my family’s beliefs. It’s butter, and only butter, all the way!